Plastic vs Wire Dog Crates — Pros & Cons

When I brought home my first rescue, I made the classic mistake of buying the cheapest crate I could find. It was wire, flimsy, and within days, my dog figured out how to push the latch open. That moment taught me a big lesson - not all dog crates are created equal.

Choosing between plastic vs wire dog crates isn’t just about price. It’s about your dog’s personality, comfort, and lifestyle. Whether you’re crate training a puppy, traveling, or just creating a safe space at home, knowing the pros and cons of each type helps you make the right call.

Plastic Dog Crates — Pros & Cons

Pros of Plastic Dog Crates

• Perfect for travel – Plastic crates are airline-approved and ideal for car rides. They create a secure, enclosed space that helps dogs feel safe during motion.

• Better for anxious dogs – The solid walls make these crates feel like dens, which helps reduce stress for dogs that prefer privacy.

• Lightweight and easy to clean – Most models are durable yet lightweight enough to move around easily, and you can wipe them down in seconds.

Cons of Plastic Dog Crates

• Less ventilation – Plastic crates can get stuffy, especially in warmer climates.

• Not as durable for chewers – Strong or anxious dogs might chew through plastic parts or damage the door over time.

• Limited visibility – Dogs that prefer seeing their surroundings might feel confined or anxious in a plastic crate.

Best for: Travel, shy or anxious dogs, and crate training in quieter environments.

Shop Durable Dog Crates at Happy Pet HQ →

Wire Dog Crates — Pros & Cons

Pros of Wire Dog Crates

• Excellent airflow and visibility – Great for warmer climates or dogs that like to see what’s going on around them.

• Highly adjustable – Most wire crates come with dividers that grow with your puppy, saving money long-term.

• Sturdy and durable – Ideal for larger or stronger breeds. Many fold flat for easy storage when not in use.

Cons of Wire Dog Crates

• Heavier and bulkier – Not ideal for travel or frequent moving.

• Less privacy – Dogs that crave quiet may feel exposed in open-wire setups.

• Rust potential – Cheaper models may rust over time if not coated properly or left outdoors.

Best for: Home use, large or active dogs, and pet owners who prioritize airflow and flexibility.

Explore Wire Dog Crates and Kennels →

Which Type Is Right for Your Dog?

Here’s a simple breakdown:

• If you travel often or have a nervous dog, plastic crates offer security and comfort.

• If your dog enjoys visibility and freedom, wire crates are the better long-term choice.

Some owners even use both — plastic crates for travel and wire ones for home use. The key is matching the crate style to your dog’s temperament and your lifestyle.

Closing Thoughts

At the end of the day, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. What matters most is that your crate feels like a safe space, not punishment. After years of training dogs, I’ve learned that the right crate can turn chaos into calm — and both wire and plastic styles can do that when used with care.

If you’re ready to upgrade your setup, explore our collection of dog kennels and crates built for durability, safety, and comfort.

FAQs About Plastic vs Wire Dog Crates

1. Are plastic crates or wire crates better for puppies?
Wire crates are often better for puppies since they include dividers and better airflow. But anxious pups might prefer the privacy of plastic crates.

2. Can dogs sleep in plastic crates overnight?
Yes, as long as there’s proper ventilation and comfort inside. Plastic crates can help anxious dogs feel secure and relaxed during sleep.

3. Do wire crates make dogs feel exposed?
Some dogs feel uneasy in open-wire crates, especially in noisy homes. You can add a cover to create a den-like feel without losing airflow.